Skip to content 
You’ve seen it happen a dozen times. You pay for a marketing campaign. A lead comes in. Your front desk calls them, gets a voicemail, and hangs up. They try again the next day—nothing. You look at your spreadsheet and see a long list of “Did Not Answer.”
You sit back and think, “These internet leads are fake. They’re just tire-kickers.”
It’s easy to blame the lead quality. But the data tells a different story. In 2025, the problem usually isn’t who is clicking your ads—it’s how you are contacting them.
As Chiropractic Marketing Specialists, we know that the difference between a “bad lead” and a “new patient” is often just a matter of timing and technology. This expert guide explains why your leads aren’t answering and how to fix your follow-up system to get them on your table.
The “5-Minute Window”: Why Timing is Everything
The shelf life of an internet lead is incredibly short. When a potential patient clicks your ad on Facebook, they are likely scrolling in bed, waiting in line at the store, or watching TV. They have a microscopic attention span.
If you wait 60 minutes to call them, the odds of contacting them drop by 1000%. By then, the dopamine hit of the “sign up” has faded. They have moved on to a new task, or worse, they have clicked on a competitor’s ad. To win, you must contact them within 5 minutes while their pain—and their decision to click—is still top-of-mind.
The Death of the Phone Call (And the Rise of SMS)
Why don’t they pick up the phone? It’s not because they aren’t real people. It’s because nobody answers unknown numbers anymore. We live in a world of spam calls and robocalls.
The shift is clear: Phone calls have a sub-20% answer rate. Text messages (SMS) have a 98% open rate.
At Chiropractic Marketing Specialist, we optimize your digital presence for the way patients actually communicate. We know that phone tag kills conversions. That’s why we build mobile-first websites featuring prominent “Click-to-Text” buttons and streamlined contact forms. We remove the friction between “I’m in pain” and “I’m booked,” ensuring your practice is easy to reach on the channels your patients prefer to use.
If your follow-up strategy relies solely on a phone call, you are failing before you start. You must send a text immediately. However, it shouldn’t sound like a robot. A simple, conversational text like, “Hi [Name], I saw you requested our Sciatica Special. Do you have a moment?” breaks through the noise and gets a response because it feels personal.
The “Double Dial” Technique
If you do call, you need to use the “Double Dial” method. This is a psychological hack that dramatically increases answer rates.
- Step 1: Call the lead. If they don’t answer, hang up.
- Step 2: Immediately call them back within 10 seconds.
Why does this work? When people see an unknown number call once, they assume it’s spam. When they see that same number call right back, their brain thinks, “This must be important; maybe it’s the school or a doctor.” It signals urgency and humanity.
The “Rule of 7”: Persistence Pays Off
Most chiropractic offices give up after the second attempt. They assume if the person was interested, they would have called back. This is false. They aren’t ignoring you because they don’t want care; they are ignoring you because they are busy.
Marketing data shows that the average conversion happens between the 5th and 7th contact attempt. You need a “nurture sequence” that gently reminds them over several days. It’s not harassment; it’s professional persistence. You are fighting for their attention so you can help them.
You are absolutely right. Since the agency doesn’t sell the automation software itself, we need to pivot the solution.
Instead of solving the problem with “robots,” we will solve it with High-Intent Marketing (SEO/PPC) and Better Web Design. The argument changes from “Let software chase them” to “Let’s get you better leads who actually want to book, so you don’t HAVE to chase them.”
Here is the rewritten section to replace “You Can’t Do This Manually”:
You Can’t Chase Everyone (Why You Need Better Leads)
Expecting your busy Front Desk CA to chase “cold” leads all day is a recipe for burnout. If you have to call a lead 7 times just to get them to answer, they probably weren’t that interested to begin with.
The solution isn’t to chase harder; it’s to target better.
This is where High-Intent Marketing wins. Instead of interrupting strangers on social media who aren’t looking for a chiropractor, we focus on capturing patients who are actively searching for you.
- The Strategy: We use Google Ads and SEO to target specific “problem-aware” keywords (e.g., “emergency sciatica relief”).
- The Difference: These patients aren’t scrolling Facebook; they are in pain and looking for a solution right now.
- The Result: These leads don’t ghost you because they are the ones reaching out to you.
Stop Letting Opportunities Slip Away.
If you are generating leads but not appointments, you don’t need more leads; you need a bucket that doesn’t leak. You are paying for opportunities and letting them slip away because of outdated follow-up methods.
At Chiropractic Marketing Specialist, we provide the “Lead Catching” engine. We don’t just send you names; we install the automation that texts, nurtures, and books them for you.
We offer a Free “Lead Leakage” Audit. We’ll review your current follow-up process and show you exactly how much revenue you are losing to “ghosts”—and how to capture it.
